Archive
Nicanor “Nicky” Perlas and Clemente Bautista says Arroyo’s Environmental Policies the Worst
Presidentiable Nicanor “Nicky” Perlas, co-author of the Philippine Agenda 21 and Clemente Bautista Jr., of the Kalikasan People’s Network for the Environment gave President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo a failing grade on its protection of the environment. In an article published in the Philippine Daily Inquirer (PDI), July 27 Perlas and Bautista said that Arroyo had been the worst when it comes to dealing with the environment.
Perlas recalls Arroyo’s shocking statement in 2001 to the multisectoral group created under the Ramos administration to ensure that development did not damage the environment., “She said she thought the pursuit of sustainable development was anti-poor.”
Perlas, a recipient of the United Nations’ Earth Warrior Award who has announced plans to run for president next year, said he thought Ms Arroyo was giving priority to antipoverty initiatives over ecological balance.
The President’s statement shocked civil society leaders and was a portent of things to come, said Perlas, who actively participated in the Edsa II people power revolt that catapulted Ms. Arroyo to power in 2001.
“Obviously, she was misinformed because the environment is the source of life, clean air, natural resources. It was like she was in a time-warp,” said Perlas, who has resigned from the council.
The Philippine Council for Sustainable Development (PCSD) had been put into hibernation since then but it was recently revived under the administration of NEDA Secretary Ralph Recto. The revival in fact counter the presidents claim that Sustainable Development is anti-poverty.
“The whole point of the (UN) Earth Summit in 1992 in Rio de Janeiro was to show that there was no conflict between the environment and development. We had a global consensus there and yet there she was saying these things 10 years after,” he said.
“The deterioration of the environment in almost every aspect could be traced to that statement eight years ago,” Perlas said.
Ms Arroyo’s record on logging and mining was the worst since the dictator Ferdinand Marcos’ ouster in 1986, according to Perlas and other green advocates.
VIEW FULL ARTICLE IN PDI “Environment suffered badly, say critics”
arroyo’s tactical error in her SONA 2009- the 4% we remember, the 96% we don’t
SONA 2009 is arroyo’s last as president. in many things last, specially in speeches, you normally want it to be your best. these are the last words that your audience will hear from you and that gives you the energy to make it the most memorable.
being the last words also makes you want to enumerate what you have stood for and yes, your accomplishments. accomplishments specially for a public office is very important as they are what you were elected to do in the first place. an office such as the presidency also transcends and goes beyond the execution part of the presidency as that office also defines the principles and beliefs that a nation adapts.
in arroyo’s last SONA has failed in these things. well, she did achieve in getting images in our minds but they are of the wrong kind. and that comes from what we think is a grave tactical error in the writing of the speech.
look at the newspapers and watch the tv news and the overwhelming last take-away and what is most talked about are two things : (a) she did not categorically say she will step down in 2010 and (b) her tirades and attacks on key opposition figures.
the tragedy is that those are two of three components of the speech. in terms of weight, those two items acount for probably less than 4% of all the words in her speech and yet here we are the morning after and that is all we are talking about.
those are the only two things we now remember and want to discuss, we did not at all pay attention nor do we remember that part of her speech that accounts for at least 96% of all the words she said – her accomplishments and achievements.
including those 4% in her speech is gross tactical error not only for the nation but more importantly from her point of view her legacy.
this ending of term speech will play a significant part in defining arroyo’s legacy as president. a big part of her legacy will that be of a president who ends her term in bitterness against those who oppose her and a presidency unable to control itself and getting pleasure in attacking her critics.
what makes that even more telling is that the critics she attacked are supposedly from the minority, a very small portion of the political landscape. one is a convicted criminal, the other a leader in congress removed from power and a senator who cussed his way into history. surely given the credentials of the critics she attacked is no match to her position as president and her huge accomplishments.
attacking these minor players belonging to the political minority showed the presidency which we are supposed to hold high stooping down to the gutter just to get some puny pot shots in. the magnitude of the attack, the stature from wher it came from and the targets has pushed the presidency of this country into a heap of toxic waste.
arroyo has been accused repeatedly of not respecting institutions and those we hold dear as a nation, this one is one more example of that. arroyo tarnished her own position, the presidency.
of all things said in her SONA, there was one thing everyone was waiting for and that was something she did not say categorically – that she will step down from power in 2010 when her term expires.
instead of categorically saying she will step down as cory aquino said in her own last SONA, arroyo gave us wordsmithing of vagueness that had a back door wide open.
arroyo did not say she will step down from power in 2010, all she gave us was this line: “I have never expressed desire to extend myself beyond my term.”
the unsaid on the topic of her plans after 2010 is that she might relent to a clamor from others for her to extend herself beyond her term. it does smell of a set-up.
arroyo has been completely silent on actions in congress on cha-cha always saying they are not involved in the efforts and that these are being done independently by them. according to her spokespersons the they are keeping their hands off and yet she has not categorically told them not to pursue it.
of course none of that we believe. we have witnessed this presidency many times over telling lies about its intent and actions. we know that in this administration words said are not exactly actions executed. and the more dangerous part – words unsaid are the actions done.
there is irony there. in fact irony is all over the place in this country of ours. we now have the leftists and militants seemingly providing us with moral direction while the rightists and the government are providing us with lies and out of moral if not illegal actions.
that is where arroyo’s legacy will sit – the 4% that we remember and the 96% that was said that we chose not to listen to. the morning after is one hell of a ride.
arroyo turns SONA 2009 into a 2010 election campaign speech
As the campaign unfolds and the candidates take to the airwaves, I ask them to talk
more about how they will build up the nation rather than tear down their opponents. Our candidates must understand the complexities of our government and what it takes to move the country forward. Give the electorate real choices and not just sweet talk….
these are good words, specially on the side of asking election opponents talking about how to build the nation rather than tear down opponents.
and yet, arroyo takes a jab at mar roxas one of the leading presidentiable candidates:
To those who want to be President, this advice: If you want something done, do it hard, do it well. Don’t pussyfoot. Just do it. Don’t say bad words in public.
and another jab at erap estrada, also a declared “undeclared” presidentiable who is also one of the leaders in the polls:
I am falsely accused, without proof, of using my office for personal profit. Many of those who accuse me of it have lifestyles and spending habits that make them walking proofs of that crime….
We can read their frustrations. They had the chance to serve this good country and they blew it by serving themselves….
Those who live in glass houses should cast no stones. Those who should be in jail should not threaten it, especially if they have been there….
this one is a reference to jose de veencia. it is also another arroyo tactic that has been done many times over – turn things around:
The noisiest critics of constitutional reform tirelessly and shamelessly attempted Cha-Cha when they thought they could take advantage of a shift in the form of government. Now that they feel they cannot benefit from it, they oppose it.
the lighting fast push for con-ass and several attempts at cha-cha speaks of arroyo wanting to benefit from its success not to mention it is widely believed cha-cha is being done for the purpose of arroyo extending her grip on power.
we have a SONA where arroyo says political candidates should stay on talks on building the country and refrain from putting each other down. and yet in this same SONA, she actually attacks 2 leading opposition presidentiables.
combine that attack on leading opposition presidentiables with hiding behind on who benefits with cha-cha plus no categorical declaration that she will step down from power in 2010 leads you to conclude she has political ambitions beyond 2010.
this SONA is more than a SONA, it is an election campaign speech.
——
read other posts:
- 9 Years Of Arroyo As President – A Review Of Arroyo’s Presidency
- Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009 a failure – half of the truth said, the other half unsaid – no categorical statement she will step down in 2010
- on the day of arroyo’s SONA 2009 – SWS survey release – hunger rose, 3 points to all time record high hunger
- arroyo turns SONA 2009 into a 2010 election campaign speech
on the day of arroyo’s SONA 2009 – SWS survey release – hunger rose, 3 points to all time record high hunger
on the day that president gloria macapagal arroyo delivered her SONA 2009, her last SONA, the SWS releases new and most recent data on their hunger survey.
it is ironic on the day the president talked about glowing achievements in the economy and welfare of the people, the people themselves spoke and said hunger rose to 20.3%, just 3 points lower than all time record high or 3.7 million families.
we can just connect the dots.


27 July 2009
Second Quarter 2009 Social Weather Survey:
Hunger rises to 20.3% of families;
Moderate Hunger is 16.0%, Severe Hunger is 4.3%Social Weather Stations
The Second Quarter 2009 Social Weather Survey, fielded over June 19-22, 2009, found the proportion of families experiencing involuntary hunger at least once in the past three months rising to 20.3% or an estimated 3.7 million families, from 15.5% or an estimated 2.9 million families in the previous quarter.
The new Hunger figure is just 3 points lower than the record-high 23.7% (or estimated 4.3 million families) in December 2008, and is 8 points above the ten-year average of 12.8% [Chart 1, Table 1].
Hunger has consistently been in double-digits for five years, since June 2004.
The SWS measure of Hunger refers to involuntary suffering because the respondents answer a survey question that specifies hunger due to lack of anything to eat.
President Arroyo’s SONA 2009 full transcript
the full transcript of arroyo’s SONA 2009 is now available in this blog, click and read here: > Full Transcript Of President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009
————————
cast your vote for your favorite presidentiable.
vote in the 2010 Presidentiables Poll,
click here: http://2010presidentiables.wordpress.com/2009/04/29/2010-presidentiables-poll-cast-your-vote/
——
read other posts:
- 9 Years Of Arroyo: A Review – Cayetano Paderanga Jr.
- Budget unbalanced, injustice in tax policy – Cielito Habito
- Employment record: Good, bad and ugly – Tomas Africa
- Education: Plugging leaks, shortages – Juan Miguel Luz
- Gloria and her SONAs: Long on show, short on substance – PCIJ
- Health: Good news with lots of buts… – Jaime Galvez Tan
- Sona 2001 revisited, Performance against targets – Ibon Foundation
- Palace stinks with scandals – Eliza Victoria, Cyril Bonabente
- At Supreme Court, she won some, lost big – Isagani Cruz
- Scandals without closure overshadow successes- juliet labog-javellana
- Environment suffered badly, say critics – philip tubeza
- Arroyo’s performance, trust ratings. It’s downhill after 2004 -Minerva Generalao, Kate V. Pedroso
- 8 State of the Nation Addresses of Arroyo
- Arroyo ‘has done little or none at all’ – PDI readers
Memo To: Presidentiable Mar Roxas – after arroyo’s SONA 2009 – shut the fuck up!
Memo to: Presidentiable Mar Roxas,
Mr. Roxas, we did hear president arroyo say these things about you:
The President minced no words against Senator Manuel Roxas, a presidential aspirant who had been criticizing her over the implementation of the cheaper medicines law.
“To those who want to be President, this advice: If you really want something done, just do it, do it hard, do it well, don’t pussy-foot, don’t say bad words in public,” she said.
Arroyo said her support for the tougher version of the law at the House of Representatives over the weaker version of the Senate, spearheaded by Roxas, resulted in a 50-percent cut in the prices of 16 essential drugs.
We understand that those are words that should have not been uttered by the president of the country to a senator. We also understand that you probably felt stung by it.
But we have this to say to you – shut the fuck up!
We advise you to let it go. We think that should you find the need to say something, say something
magnanimous and with prime statemanship. Show the country you are no longer the angry man we saw say “putang ina” in a rally of thousands in makati.
Take pride in the fact that you are one of the few presidentiables that arroyo felt the need to mention in her SONA. That can only mean you have been effective in your stand on arroyo and in particular the low priced medicine law.
Arroyo unwittingly made you appear as the front runner for the presidentiable election in 2010.
Letting it go or giving a reply with humility and statemanship will improve your image.
Please Mr. Roxas, do not forget for now, shut the fuck up!
Yours truly,
~wawam~
PS :
Mr. Mar Roxas;
We suggest you send President Arroyo a beautiful bouquet of roses tomorrow morning as a thank you. That will earn you many points.
Take the opposite side of what arroyo showed in her SONA – be a gentleman and show humility. You do not need to say anything. Just send her the flowers and sign your name.
Take arroyo’s uncalled for tirade against you (and the opposition) in a very different tact. What she said was uncalled for and did at all fit the spirit and intent of the SONA. Make her appear as evil.
~wawam~
Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009 a failure – half of the truth said, the other half unsaid – no categorical statement she will step down in 2010
this SONA 2009, supposedly arroyo;s last SONA is classic arroyo – say half the truth, keep the other half a secret, while the other half that has been unsaid is the more important part.
the filipino people want to hear one and only one thing – her plans after 2010. the people want to hear a categorical statement that she will step down from power in 2010.
arroyo cannot say she does not know this is what the people want to hear. this is clear in all the surveys where the people want her out. aside from the surveys, key political figures, ramos one among them have categorically said arroyo need to let the nation know that she will step down from power in 2010. that says she has no excuse to ignore that desire, not to say it.
what we got is one half of the truth or so at least that is what she wants us to think – “I have never expressed desire to extend myself beyond my term.”
what she said there is that she has not uttered the words “i want to extend her term”, she did not say she did not want it in her mind. it is possible it is in her mind, but she just did not say it.
that statement sets us up for what might be next – it can happen where the congressmen she controls at the lower house will launch a ”clamor” for her to be the leader beyond her term. she can say the call for her to stay beyond 2010 is not coming from her, not her desire but the desire of the congressmen to do so. she will then in all humility accept the clamor and challenge and extend her term.
that is the last half of the truth that she did not “utter” today. this is classic arroyo.
Arroyo: No ‘expressed desire’ to extend term
By Joel Guinto
INQUIRER.net
First Posted 16:07:00 07/27/2009(UPDATE 3) President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo said she “never expressed desire” to extend her term beyond 2010, but still kept the nation guessing on her political plans as she delivered her ninth and final State of the Nation Address (Sona).
“I have never expressed desire to extend myself beyond my term, many of those who accuse me of it try to cling like nails to their posts,” said Arroyo, who was wearing a bright purple terno.
“At the end of this speech, I shall step down from this stage but not from the presidency. My term does not end until next year. Until then, I will fight for the ordinary Filipino. The nation comes first. There is much to do as head of state to the very last day,” she said.
“A year is a long time. We will continue to invest in the economy, the environment, and education,” she said, adding that after her ninth and supposedly last Sona, it would be “more work” not “all politics.”
—–
cast your vote for your favorite presidentiable.
vote in the 2010 Presidentiables Poll,
click here: http://2010presidentiables.wordpress.com/2009/04/29/2010-presidentiables-poll-cast-your-vote/
——
read other posts:
- 9 Years Of Arroyo: A Review – Cayetano Paderanga Jr.
- Budget unbalanced, injustice in tax policy – Cielito Habito
- Employment record: Good, bad and ugly – Tomas Africa
- Education: Plugging leaks, shortages – Juan Miguel Luz
- Gloria and her SONAs: Long on show, short on substance – PCIJ
- Health: Good news with lots of buts… – Jaime Galvez Tan
- Sona 2001 revisited, Performance against targets – Ibon Foundation
- Palace stinks with scandals – Eliza Victoria, Cyril Bonabente
- At Supreme Court, she won some, lost big – Isagani Cruz
- Scandals without closure overshadow successes- juliet labog-javellana
- Environment suffered badly, say critics – philip tubeza
- Arroyo’s performance, trust ratings. It’s downhill after 2004 -Minerva Generalao, Kate V. Pedroso
- 8 State of the Nation Addresses of Arroyo
- Arroyo ‘has done little or none at all’ – PDI readers
On Arroyo’s State Of The Nation Address, this is the state of nation’s mind
in today’s State Of The Nation Address of president gloria macapagal arroyo, the state of the nation’s mind is that of high mistrust and a much bigger dose of skepticism.
cardinal gaudencio rosales, the archibishop of manila, the highest in the catholic church’s heirarchy in the philippines sums it up very well – “tell the truth”.
for a bishop to tell that to the president of the country speaks volumes. in normal times with a normal presidency, the truth is a given and something that need not be told to the highest elective position of the country to speak.
the SONA would have been a time to celebrate achievements of the past and a time to generate excitement for the future. SONAs do not only speak of past achievements but what are the plans and programs for the future that builds on the past.
and that is where the problem lie. this is a presidency that does not have a stellar past. if anything, it is quite the opposite. this is a presidency plagued by scandals, missteps, lies that have been found out and a huge does of in-denial.
while we know it is unrealistic to expect a perfect presidency, what we expect is a presidency that owns up to errors and weaknesses and measure to correct them and improve upon.
that is not the arroyo presidency. this is a presidency who will never, ever own up to errors, mistakes or weaknesses. it is a presidency who likes to talk and in fact boast only of the good and the great even if we all know they are not true.
lies is the foundation of this presidency, from the grand to the trivial. the latest trivial lie of which is on arroyo’s breast implants. these small and huge lies have contributed to the skepticism we have harbored and percolated over the years.
this poisonous brew shows up everywhere – a presidency that has gotten dismal results in performance and trust ratings quarter to quarter of opinion polls across many years.
the mind of the nation was not as poisoned as it is now. but what is that we can do? the poison was there for us to see and shoved into our minds by arroyo herself. and that is what is the state of mind of the nation on this day of state of the nation address of arroyo – a hunger for truth.
STATE OF NATION
Bishop to Arroyo: ‘Just tell the truth’
Talk about accomplishments, mistakesBy Norman Bordadora, Tonette Orejas, Chito A. Fuentes
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 00:40:00 07/27/2009MANILA, Philippines—Manila Archbishop Gaudencio Cardinal Rosales Sunday asked President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo to tell the true state
of the nation when she delivers her address before a joint session of Congress
Monday afternoon.
Rosales said Ms Arroyo should tell the truth not only about her accomplishments but also about her mistakes as her term ends next year, the CBCP news website reported Sunday.
“She (has) also done something good, and people will not take it against her if she mentions them,” Rosales was quoted as saying.
“Next year will be different, that’s why she has to tell what is true—that’s what people want to hear,” he added.
University of the Philippines professor Randy David and Sen. Francis Escudero also urged Ms Arroyo to tell the people the real score in her State of the Nation Address (SONA), her ninth since she took power in 2001.
“But perhaps, the usual boasting will be done again,” David said, calling on Filipinos to scrutinize Ms Arroyo’s supposed achievements on the economic front.
———–
read other posts:
- 9 Years Of Arroyo As President – A Review Of Arroyo’s Presidency
- Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009 a failure – half of the truth said, the other half unsaid – no categorical statement she will step down in 2010
- on the day of arroyo’s SONA 2009 – SWS survey release – hunger rose, 3 points to all time record high hunger
- arroyo turns SONA 2009 into a 2010 election campaign speech
gloria macapagal arroyo’s SONA 2009 in pictures

how much truth will arroyo’s SONA 2009 have? will we be dazzled with huge claims to achievements? or will it be just speak no evil, see no evil and hear no evil all over again? arroyo’s speeches often always misses the point or hides the truth be it in half or the whole truth.
malacanang has said cha-cha will be tackled. if that is true, then that is just half the truth we want. the other half is what are the plans of arroyo after 2010? or is that the evil part that we will not see, not hear and not be spoken?
———-
read other posts:
- 9 Years Of Arroyo As President – A Review Of Arroyo’s Presidency
- Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009 a failure – half of the truth said, the other half unsaid – no categorical statement she will step down in 2010
- on the day of arroyo’s SONA 2009 – SWS survey release – hunger rose, 3 points to all time record high hunger
- arroyo turns SONA 2009 into a 2010 election campaign speech
President Cory Aquino’s Last SONA – Will Arroyo’s SONA measure up?
this is the very last part of Cory’s last SONA. it nevertheless contains what probably the most important part that president arroyo should copy.
more about how they will build up the nation rather than tear down their opponents. Our candidates must understand the complexities of our government and what it takes to move the country forward. Give the electorate real choices and not just sweet talk….
of the nation when she delivers her address before a joint session of 
we are opening a new page in this blog where we will post reviews and opinions on the presidency of gloria macapagal arroyo.
Readers Speak Up