Bel-Air Scam – barangay level corruption at Barangay Bel-Air Makati, yes Makati!
Graft Bel-Air style
August 28, 2013 11:00 pm
by Joel M. Sy Egco Assignments Editor
THERE is an old notion that rich people do not steal but recent studies have exploded this myth.In January 2012, researchers from the universities of California and Toronto who conducted seven studies that used experimental and naturalistic methods found out that rich people “are more apt to behave unethically than those who had less money.”
Experts noted that the “relative independence” and “increased privacy” of the affluent make them more likely to cheat, break the law or behave badly toward others.
“. . . unethical tendencies are accounted for, in part, by their more favorable attitudes toward greed,” the study, published in the Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences, said.
Wealthy Filipinos are no exception, if reports about the massive misuse of public money by the rich and powerful are to be believed.
The names of the powerful and the wealthy have been dragged into the controversy involving the abuse and misuse of billions of pesos granted to lawmakers as their Priority Development Assistance Funds (PDAF) or “pork barrel.”
At least five senators, several congressmen, local executives and traders have been embroiled in the controversy which, on Monday, led to the biggest protest rally so far during the time of President Benigno Aquino 3rd.
But corruption is not confined to the hallowed halls of Congress. It persists even in the most basic or smallest unit of government—the barangay—which operates using funds from tax collections and the internal revenue allotment (IRA) share of a certain town or city.
Corruption occurs in rich and poor barangays, and it manifests in various forms—a garbage contract that runs in the millions or simply in the award of a food supply contract to a favored bidder, who may turn out to be a relative or even the husband or a daughter-in-law of a local elective official.
The Bel-Air experience
Take for instance the string of criminal and administrative charges that have been filed against officials of Barangay Bel-Air, a wealthy enclave in the heart of Makati City’s upscale district.Bel-Air officials were charged for allegedly favoring a private food supplier whose registered owners are close relatives of the incumbent village chief, Constancia “Nene” Lichauco.
Based on documents obtained by The Manila Times, incumbent and former officials of Bel-Air had been the subject of an investigation by the Office of the Ombudsman.
Besides Lichauco, councilor Conchita Caluag and Leonila Querijero, budget chief of the University of Makati City, were even recommended for a six-month suspension “without pay” by the Ombudsman’s Field Investigation Office (FIO) in February.
Likewise named respondents in the case were Zoilo Lindo, former barangay treasurer; Karen Mendoza, former councilor; Ignacio Macrohon, Jr., former chairman of the committee on canvass; and Rosario Dimayuga, also a former a councilor and member of the canvass committee.The case stemmed from a P116,900 service contract allegedly signed by Lichauco with Two Chefs Corporation, a local food provider, for the supply of food and drinks during a supposed Sangguniang Barangay meeting in March 2007; Pasinaya Parade in April 2007; and Flores de Mayo in May 2007.
On March 12, 2007 a purchase request was prepared by Lindo Jr., then the barangay treasurer. Lichauco approved the request.
The next day, the committee on canvass submitted an Abstract of Canvass and Award, naming Two Chefs Corporation as the choice supplier, having offered “the lowest and most reasonable price obtainable in the market at the time of the canvass.”
It was later established that Two Chefs was represented by Patricia Warren-Lichauco, the barangay captain’s daughter-in-law.
It gets more interesting. Based on another set of documents from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) obtained by the Times, the incorporators of the catering firm are Lichauco’s own husband, Francisco; her son, German Lichauco 2nd; and other daughters-in-law, Ma. Liza Jabson Lichauco and Maria Teresa Roxas Lichauco.
The Lichaucos were also named as private respondents in the recommended criminal case.
Moro-moro
Investigators found out that the canvass done on March 13, where two other food suppliers—Kusinerong Pinoy Catering Services and Marj Food and Catering Services—appeared to be a moro-moro or sham because the service contract with Two Chefs had been signed and notarized as early as March 2, 2007, or 11 days prior to the actual canvass.Even the Commission on Audit (COA) branch in Makati City claimed that the service contract dated March 2, 2007 of Two Chefs Corp “does not include a Sanggunian Resolution or ordinance authorizing the Punong Barangay of Barangay Bel-Air to enter into said contract.”
During an investigation by Associate Graft Investigative Officer 3 Janice O. Baltazar, who recommended the filing of charges against the respondents on Valentine’s Day this year, it was gathered that Fernando Zuñiga, who was the barangay secretary in 2007, said he “cannot recall if there was a Barangay Resolution passed.”
The present barangay secretary, on the other hand, reasoned out that the resolution was “either misplaced or lost” due to the transfer of offices of the barangay hall.
Baltazar immediately sensed something was wrong. “The act of issuing said documents including the Certificate of Purchase and delivery of Supplies is merely a scheme to make it appear that the transaction with respondent Two Chefs Corporation is not tainted with any irregularity by showing that the service contract was executed in accordance [with] the result of a personal canvass, when in fact, no such personal canvass was made by [Lichauco] for purposes of availing a catering service from a dealer with the lowest offer,” she said.
“The series of events, conditions and circumstances lead to the fact that there is conspiracy among the abovementioned public officials/employees and private individuals. Taken altogether, each and everyone of them contributed and participated in the realization of the illicit purpose of favoring or preferring [Two Chefs]…” the graft investigator said.
Baltazar said that Lichauco, “in conspiracy” with the other officials and the favored bidder, “violated Section 3 (e) of RA [Republic Act] 3019 otherwise known as the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act” by giving undue advantage to Two Chefs “through evident bad faith, manifest partiality or, at the very least, through gross inexcusable negligence.”
Likewise, the respondents violated Article 171 paragraph 4 (falsification by public officer/employee by making untruthful statements in a narration of facts) of the Revised Penal Code when they issued the Price Canvass reports, Abstract of Canvass and Award, Purchase request “which showed that a personal canvass was conducted for the purpose of securing a service contract when in fact there was none.”
Lichauco “further violated the same law when she signed the service contract stating that she is authorized to act in behalf of the barangay when in fact there is no showing from the records that she is indeed authorized,” Baltazar said.
The investigator noted that the respondents violated Section 3 (h) of RA 3019, which prohibits officials from “directly or indirectly having financial or pecuniary interest in any business, contract or transaction in connection with which he intervenes or takes part in his official capacity, or in which he is prohibited by the Constitution or by any law from having any interest.”
Baltazar said the respondents could be liable for serious dishonesty, grave misconduct, falsification of official document and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service under the rules of the Civil Service Commission.
However, Macrohon Jr., Mendoza, Lindo, Jr., and Dimayuga can no longer be charged administratively because they are no longer connected with the government.
(To be continued)
-
October 10, 2013 at 11:07 ambarangay bel-air nene lichauco speaks out on bel-air corruption articles | WAWAM! after hours
1 Million hits and going...
- 1,728,943 hits
wawam on Twitter
- RT @ClutchPointsApp: "That was God disguised as Michael Jordan." This was all Larry Bird had to say as MJ poured in 63 points, which still… ... wawam tweeted 10 hours ago
- RT @UAWeapons: #Ukraine: A Russian BTR-82A armored personnel carrier was destroyed on a mine field in #Kharkiv Oblast. As seen on the video… ... wawam tweeted 10 hours ago
- RT @PhilstarNews: Cash aid amounting to P147,000 intended for 35 people was claimed by just one person in Magalang town in Pampanga, contra… ... wawam tweeted 10 hours ago
- RT @diwatabea: Hello @NYPDChiefOfDept, we're afraid this guy named "Ernest Leigh" is stalking the Vice President of the Philippines while i… ... wawam tweeted 12 hours ago
- RT @krixiasINQ: President Duterte will leave a government that has “failed in its obligations to protect human rights” and “encouraged a cu… ... wawam tweeted 17 hours ago
- RT @CNN: Taylor Swift gave the commencement speech at NYU's graduation at Yankee Stadium — and received an honorary doctorate of fine arts.… ... wawam tweeted 17 hours ago
- RT @nyuniversity: "I know it can be really overwhelming figuring out who to be, and when. Who you are now and how to act in order to get wh… ... wawam tweeted 19 hours ago
- RT @lenispinks: ladies and gentlemen, the robredos. ✨ https://t.co/VJdcq8cFyR ... wawam tweeted 20 hours ago
- RT @inquirerdotnet: Ana Patricia Non who was recognized by the US Embassy as the recipient of the Ambassador’s Woman of Courage Award, shar… ... wawam tweeted 20 hours ago
- RT @PhilstarNews: "We love you, Jillian! Alam mo bang lagi kitang ipinagmamalak?" Tricia Robredo wrote in her Instagram post. ... wawam tweeted 20 hours ago
- RT @inquirerdotnet: Vice President Leni Robredo’s daughter, Tricia, has called out netizens making fun of red-tagging and martial law atroc… ... wawam tweeted 21 hours ago
- funny! twitter.com/colbertlatesho… ... wawam tweeted 21 hours ago
Most Read Posts Today
- what is "TRAPO"?
- how did sex education become immoral and leads to wrong moral development?
- adding 2 more years to basic education will further widen the rich & poor divide
- Leni Robredo's trek to the vice president position : part 1
- ateneo de manila department of psychology's report on noynoy aquino's mental health
- > Education: Plugging leaks, shortages - Juan Miguel Luz
- red flag alert for manny villar - a C-5 controversy take down in the horizon
- Demokrasya: Isang tula handog para kina Ninoy at Cory Aquino
- remains of cory aquino now at la salle greenhills
- revilla, enrile, estrada, marcos, lanette & 23 other lawmakers contributed their pork barrel funds to P10B "mother of all scams" - PDI
Recent Posts
- teen Nikki Vicente on EJKs – “sana may paki tayo”
- UNHR: “The President-elect (Duterte) fools no one when he says he is not calling on people to be killed.”
- change has arrived – PDI uses the word “fuck” on its front page, a first in PHL journalism
- 4th presidential debate transcript here
- why Rody Duterte is wrong for the country – he inspires us be our worst #2016PHVote
comments & reactions
top rated posts, comments & sections
comments, suggestions & inquiries
Read Other Sections:
- First Report of the IIRC on the Rizal Park Hostage-taking Incident
- Noynoy Aquino Landslide Win
- Pope Benedict On Condom Use
- President Noynoy Aquino’s Campaign Promises
- The Noynoy Aquino Presidency
- Gloria Macapagal Arroyo – Reviews
- > 8 State of the Nation Addresses of Arroyo
- > 9 Years Of Arroyo: A Review – Cayetano Paderanga Jr.
- > Arroyo ‘has done little or none at all’ – PDI readers
- > Arroyo’s performance, trust ratings. It’s downhill after 2004 -Minerva Generalao, Kate V. Pedroso
- > At Supreme Court, she won some, lost big – Isagani Cruz
- > Budget unbalanced, injustice in tax policy – Cielito Habito
- > Business unhappy with Arroyo performance
- > Education: Plugging leaks, shortages – Juan Miguel Luz
- > Employment record: Good, bad and ugly – Tomas Africa
- > Environment suffered badly, say critics – philip tubeza
- > Gloria and her SONAs: Long on show, short on substance – PCIJ
- > Health: Good news with lots of buts… – Jaime Galvez Tan
- > Palace stinks with scandals – Eliza Victoria, Cyril Bonabente
- > Scandals without closure overshadow successes- juliet labog-javellana
- > Sona 2001 revisited, Performance against targets – Ibon Foundation
- > Full Transcript Of President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s SONA 2009
- No To Con-Ass HR 1109!
- Reproductive Health Bill 5043
- 160 Ateneo De Manila University Professors declare support for the RH Bill
- 33 more ateneo professors support rh bill, now 192 professors
- 63.9% of pinays risk unplanned pregnancy – FPS
- 8 REASONS WHY CATHOLICS SUPPORT RH by Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago
- A Jesuit Sociologist on RH Bill by John J. Carroll, S.J.
- ADB : Poverty In the Philippines – causes, constraints & opportunities
- amendments to House Bill 4244 – consolidated reproductive health bill
- ateneo president fr villarin ignores bishop, upholds independent thinking and appreciates ateneo professors efforts on rh bill
- ateneo upholding academic freedom : “The university has its own purposes which cannot be subordinated to other objectives”
- based on serious evidence, the RH Bill is pro-poor and authentically pro-life & pro-family – UP Economics Professors
- bishop wants pro rh bill Ateneo professors fired – hahahaha
- catholic bishops’ dirty words against RH Bill supporters – unchristian accusations
- CBCP answers fr joaquin bernas on rh bill via print ad at philippine daily inquirer
- consolidated reproductive health bill full text – House Bill RH 4244
- de la salle university professors support the rh bill – “rh bill is pro-life”
- fr. bernas answers bishop reyes & the CBCP : points out where the bishop erred on rh bill
- Fr. Joaquin Bernas on #rhbill : serves the welfare of the nation and especially of poor women who cannot afford the cost of medical service
- homily on Humanae Vitae by bishop lagdameo
- how anti RHBill proponents fail to reproduce logic, the senator miriam speech
- Humanae Vitae encyclical – basis for catholic church’s stand on birth control (read text)
- is representative manny pacquaio helping or hurting the cause of anti-RH Bill proponents?
- joint statement of ateneo and UP professors : Pass The RH Bill Now
- Philippines National Demographic and Health Survey 2008
- pulse asia survey : high 73% agree with RH Bill – october 2010 survey
- Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago’s sponsorship speech (part 1) on the RH Bill – transcript
- senator sotto’s legacy- sotto makes it to New York Times on the rh bill
- sotto on #rhbill is the laughing stock of social media, he victimized himself – patricia evangelista
- teaching of my church is to respect beliefs of other religions – Fr. Bernas SJ on the RH Bill
- the continuing saga of Sarah Pope, the blogger senator tito sotto plagiarized
- UN Study – birth control needed for PH to benefit from eco growth
- UP and Ateneo professors issues support on RH Bill
- UP School Of Economics : Population, Poverty, Politics and the Reproductive Health Bill
- wawam tweet on UST Varsitarian’s article attacking Ateneo & Las Salle professors stand on RH Bill shown on gma NewsTV
- why pinoys who are single or married need family planning in their relationship
- Catholics Can Support The RH Bill In Good Conscience – Ateneo Professors’ Position Paper RH Bill 5043
- RH Bill 5043 SWS Survey – 71% of catholics agree with the RH Bill
- RH Bill No. 5043 Full Text
- UP School Of Economics : Population, Poverty, Politics and the Reproductive Health Bill
- US Presidential Election
contribute to this blog, contact us
Topics Covered Here
- 2010 election results
- 2010 philippine presidential election
- 2010 Presidentiables Face-Off
- 2010 Presidentiables milestones
- 2010 Presidentiables Poll- vote here
- 2010 SWORDS
- 2013 elections
- 2013 Senatoriables
- 2016 Election Marketing
- 2016 elections
- 2016 presidentiables
- ADS? Sindrome
- advocacies
- alan peter cayetsno
- antonio trillanes
- aquino administration
- aquino to lose election
- ariel querubin
- attack ads
- automated election
- bayani fernando
- bayani fernando tv ads
- bishop lagdameo
- bongbong marcos
- bro. eddie villanueva
- cardinal rosales
- catholic church
- Celebrations
- cerge remonde
- cha-cha (charter change)
- chesley sullenberger
- chief justice puno
- Chief Justice Renato Corona impeachment
- chiz escudero
- chiz escudero tv ads
- comelec
- cory aquino
- Cyber Crime Law
- ed panlilio
- eddie villanueva
- eddie villanueva ads
- EDSA people power revolution
- edu manzano
- edwin lacierda
- ellipsis
- endorsement ads for consumer brands
- erap estrada
- erap estrada tv ads
- filipino voters
- fr. joaquin bernas sj
- francis pangilinan
- gilbert teodoro
- gilbert teodoro tv ads
- gloria macapagal arroyo
- GMA7 Isang Tanong
- governor ed panlilio
- grace poe
- gringo honasan
- Hermogenes Ebdane
- how to lose a philippine presidential election
- how to win philippine elections
- Internet Freedom Bill
- jaime cardinal sin
- jamby madrigal
- jc de los reyes
- jejomar binay
- jojo binay
- juan ponce enrile
- Kahindik-hindik
- kris aquino
- leila de lima
- leni robredo
- liza maza
- loren legarda
- loren legarda ads
- manila hostage
- Manny Pacquiao
- manny villar
- manny villar tv ads
- many villar website
- mar roxas
- mar roxas tv ads
- martial law
- memo to presidentiables
- Memo To:
- mike velarde
- military
- mindscape landmark
- miriam santiago
- moral force
- NDCC
- negative campaign ads
- nene pimentel
- Nicanor Perlas
- noli de castro
- noynoy aquino
- noynoy aquino kahindik-hindik
- noynoy aquino palapakpakan
- noynoy aquino tv ads
- ombudsman
- opposition
- P10B pork barrel scam
- PDAF
- PDI Talk Of The Town
- philippine advertising
- philippine economy
- philippine education
- philippine elections
- philippine media
- philippine senate
- ping lacson
- platform of government
- political ads
- political tv ads
- politics in the philippines
- pork barrel
- presidentiable polls
- presidentiables
- presidentiables brand positioning
- presidentiables stand on issues
- presidentiables twitter acount
- presidential debates
- pulse asia
- Quick Read
- ralph recto
- Randy David
- readers reactions
- reproductive health
- RH Bill 5043
- RH Law
- richard gordon
- richard gordon tv ads
- rody duterte
- ronaldo puno
- SAF44
- satur ocampo
- senatoriables
- social media
- SONA
- surveys & polls
- SWS
- The 2010 Presidentiables Blog
- The 2010 Presidentiables Victory Forum
- the presidency of noynoy aquino
- The Victory Forum
- the wawam blogs
- UNA
- Uncategorized
- US politics
- vice presdientiables
- vice-presidentiable
- vice-presidentiables
- WAWAM!
- what a waste of advertising money
- why aquino will lose the election
- why gilbert teodoro will lose the election
- why manny villar will lose the election
Archives
- August 2017 (1)
- June 2016 (2)
- April 2016 (4)
- March 2016 (5)
- February 2016 (11)
- January 2016 (4)
- December 2015 (2)
- November 2015 (1)
- October 2015 (4)
- September 2015 (4)
- July 2015 (1)
- June 2015 (2)
- March 2015 (1)
- January 2015 (4)
- December 2014 (1)
- November 2014 (4)
- October 2014 (5)
- September 2014 (4)
- May 2014 (4)
- April 2014 (2)
- March 2014 (1)
- January 2014 (1)
- November 2013 (1)
- October 2013 (5)
- August 2013 (1)
- July 2013 (7)
- June 2013 (1)
- March 2013 (7)
- February 2013 (3)
- January 2013 (8)
- December 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (4)
- October 2012 (2)
- September 2012 (10)
- August 2012 (9)
- July 2012 (6)
- June 2012 (1)
- May 2012 (6)
- April 2012 (1)
- March 2012 (5)
- February 2012 (1)
- January 2012 (7)
- December 2011 (2)
- November 2011 (3)
- October 2011 (6)
- September 2011 (3)
- August 2011 (1)
- July 2011 (6)
- May 2011 (11)
- April 2011 (11)
- March 2011 (3)
- February 2011 (1)
- January 2011 (4)
- December 2010 (3)
- November 2010 (5)
- October 2010 (8)
- September 2010 (9)
- August 2010 (7)
- July 2010 (16)
- June 2010 (11)
- May 2010 (59)
- April 2010 (53)
- March 2010 (34)
- February 2010 (36)
- January 2010 (32)
- December 2009 (35)
- November 2009 (56)
- October 2009 (36)
- September 2009 (41)
- August 2009 (59)
- July 2009 (74)
- June 2009 (33)
- May 2009 (19)
- April 2009 (8)
- March 2009 (14)
- February 2009 (8)
- January 2009 (30)
- December 2008 (18)
- November 2008 (12)
Readers Speak Up